Emily Wilson Talks Translation, Perspective, And More
Written by Bwog Staff
Emily Wilson, whose translation of Homer’s Odyssey replaced Lattimore’s edition on the Literature Humanities syllabus this year, visited Columbia on Wednesday night for a lecture. Editor in Chief Youngweon Lee and Newsletter Editor Zoe Sottile attended.
It’s become something of a trope of profiles on women artists/ leaders/people to comment on what they wear. Awareness of this trope is why we are reluctant to mention that Emily Wilson, professor of Classical Studies at the University of Pennsylvania and the first woman to translate Homer’s Odyssey into English, showed up to last night’s event in Dodge 501 wearing shiny gold sneakers and an owl-emblazoned t-shirt (the owl is the sigil of Athena). But she did. And she looked so cool.
Wilson, whose translation of the Odyssey was recently added to Columbia College’s Literature Humanities syllabus, gave a fast and far-encompassing talk on literary translation, modern classicists, and the Greek epics. The drawing studio in Dodge 501, repurposed for the night, filled up fast: towards the end of the night, people were turned away as the room reached capacity. The event started with a general talk from Wilson about her translation, moved onto a PowerPoint presentation with which she went over some specific example passages, and ended with a Q&A.
She began the night, poignantly, with a criticism of her most frequent moniker: first woman to have translated the Odyssey into English. She pointed out that this is a uniquely English problem, as the Odyssey has been translated into other languages, like French or German, by women. Moreover, she noted that in interviews she is frequently reduced to her gender, often answering the same question of “how did your female perspective influence your translation?” over and over again. (When the question period rolled around later in the night, no one asked this.)
She then discussed many of the choices that make her translation unique: writing in iambic pentameter, matching Homer line for line, her use of relatively modern instead of archaic language, switching up his repetitive epithets. While Homer has been translated in verse before, her version’s closeness to the Homeric structure sets it apart.
She explained that her choice to use iambic pentameter came from the fact that it’s the meter of Shakespeare and Milton and thus would convey in English what Homer’s dactylic hexameter conveys in Greek. Wilson also mirrored the relatively simple and straightforward syntax of the Odyssey and explained that while Homer uses long sentences, they’re not complicated. She said during the Q&A session that she used fewer syllables to fit the shorter pentameter, but not fewer words, noting that this would be extremely difficult for, say, the Aeneid, as Latin (especially Vergilian) is a much denser language. As for the repetition that is very typical to Homer and to the oral tradition, she noted the difference between an oral culture and a literate one and explained that she chose to keep the repetitive lines, just not word-for-word. As an example of this, Wilson gave her variations of a line that described dawn bringing sunrise in her PowerPoint presentation.
Another major point of her talk was the importance of perspective in the Odyssey. She pointed out that while many translators highlight Odysseus’s perspective at the expense of other characters—in particular, his victims—the original Greek actually takes care to bring those characters to life. In many ways, she remarked, the Odyssey is about who gets to come home and who doesn’t. “Odysseus gets home,” she noted, “but he gets home through violence and enslavement.”
She brought up the passage of the hanging of the slavegirls (who had lain with the suitors after the slaughter in the great hall) as an example to support her point; while many translators use the word “slut” (Fagles, Fitzgerald, Lombardo), “whore” (Fagles), or “creatures” (Lattimore, whose translation was in the LitHum syllabus until last year) for how Telemachus refers to them, her translation opts to emphasize their tainted nature as remnants of the suitors rather than their promiscuity. In her eyes, they were just trying to get “home” as much as Odysseus was, even if that meant making concessions to the enemy to regain some semblance of normality. But while Odysseus gets his homecoming, their fate is far more grisly.
Another thing to note about this passage and other translators’ choice to add in “words of abuse,” as Wilson called them, is that they are not there in the Greek. Homer’s line reads “τάων, αἵ…” for the part translated as “sluts,” “whores,” etc., which is literally just two pronouns in the feminine plural in different cases. Wilson translates this as simply (and literally) “these girls.”
Odyssey via Owen Fitzgerald-Diaz
Tags: ABOUT TIME lattimore got REPLACED bYE lol, anne carson and emily wilson are my two heroes, cannot believe she graced us with her presence... a queen, i wish this translation was out when i was taking lithum, i've been complaining about lattimore's translation for three years haha, imo this translation's actually the best one out there in terms of accuracy and style, lecturehop