On Thursday, November 12, Staff Writer Keahi Harper and Arts Editor Tyche Rose attended Catfight: NYU vs. Columbia, a stand-up comedy showcase raising money for cancer research.

Last week, Columbia’s stand-up comedy group Memento Mori collaborated with College Vs. Cancer, an organization founded by Nick Kroll, Niccole Kroll, and Jen Rogers that seeks to fund cancer research at university hospitals and bring together college communities fighting for the cause. Together they presented “Catfight,” a showdown between Memento Mori and NYU’s stand-up troop Astor Place Riots, and a fun yet deeply informational event. The emcees were Columbia’s Stella Turowsky-Ganci (CC ’28) and NYU’s Sanjay Vattamreddy (NYU ’27), who led the event and curated an entertaining environment in between comic performances.

The show opened with NYU comedian Sam Froum (NYU ’29). Shaking his fist, Froum announced he was excited to participate in the “totally real rivalry” between NYU and Columbia. He brought a lot of energy to the stage, speaking about the suburbs versus the city and how his childhood experiences have shaped his life now. Sharing that he was a late bloomer, Froum declared that some kids bloomed way too early. “My friend started watching porn in fifth grade,” he shared, and he thinks that’s absurd: “You shouldn’t be watching porn on an ipad with handles.”

Next was Columbia’s turn. Juliette Jiménez (BC ’27) took the floor and launched into a plot summary of the “Unnamed Abba Jukebox Musical” she wrote and produced as a counselor at Jewish sleepaway camp. At the musical’s climax, protagonist Ronald (who works at an unnamed hamburger joint) hugs his friend Chuck, “which the audience interpreted as me adding a gay plot twist to the camp musical. I didn’t deny this.” Jiménez continued with more stories from camp, such as how campers distinguished her from her bunkmate, also named Juliette, by the nicknames “Top Juliette” and “Bottom Juliette.” Jiménez invited us to guess which one she was. Finally she announced, “I was Top Juliette”—applause resounded—“Which is also my nickname at Columbia.”

Likewise, NYU’s next comedian, Wesley Himelhoch (NYU ’28), earned instant applause from the audience solely at his declaration of bisexuality. His routine was the most chaotic of the night. He performed a reenactment of himself skipping along at the moment when a stranger had hurled a homophobic insult at him; Himelhoch toppled to the ground, stared at us, and professed, “There’s moments in your life when you have to sit your white ass down and listen…” The crowd laughed, and Himelhoch immediately switched to his next bit: “I’m gonna talk about AI.” A moment later he remarked, “What is my favorite part of the Charlie Kirk video? Thank you for asking…”

Evin Schwartz (BC ’28) opened with an anecdote about their parents’ divorce, after which they had to sleep on a pull-out couch at their step-siblings’ home. This was awkward because “my step-sister is a porn star and my step brother is an Orthodox Jew…Whenever I would roll onto something I’d wonder, ‘Is this a dildo or a Torah scroll?’” Schwartz moved on to stories about their recent top surgery and their time working at McDonald’s before the surgery. They were “busty in that quarter zip,” which they believe was the biggest selling point of the store.

NYU’s final comedian, Piper Guiney (NYU ’28), centered her material around the NYU experience, from internships, to the growing “cigarette crisis” on campus, to rich kids searching for a “struggle to pull from” to seem interesting. Later in her set, she tried out some crowd work. Asking the audience if we’d seen Heated Rivalry (everyone cheered), she asked the older gentleman sitting in front (incidentally, Nick Kroll’s brother) if he liked the show. The man shook his head. “Too much hockey?” she asked. He shook his head again: “Not good stick handling.” Guiney replied, “I disagree.”

Like the other Columbia comedians, Columbia’s Beau Gantz (CC ’28) took a linear, story-based approach to his material. Gantz spoke about the two karate lessons he took at age seven: “I went in with a white belt and came out with an orange belt, which was unprecedented.” After a successful first karate lesson, his parents took him out for a celebratory dinner at a Chinese restaurant, where he learned he was born in the year of the cock. We laughed at the image of his seven-year-old self exclaiming, “Mom and Dad, I’m a cock!” Then Gantz said, “You guys think that’s funny, imagine how funny it is if you’re my parents…Imagine I’m your son…Imagine I’m your sweet boy…Imagine you love me…Imagine you’re proud of me.” The story culminated in his spilling orange crush soda on his karate gi and being reprimanded by Sensei Jared, to whom the seven-year-old Gantz allegedly bowed and replied, “You can call me Mr. Cock.” And he never returned to karate ever again.

After the student performances, the spotlight shifted to the two cancer research doctors attending the event: Dr. John Leonard, a hematologist and medical oncologist at NYU Langone, and Dr. Aaron Viny, a hematologist, oncologist, and physician-scientist at Columbia. Dr. Viny told the story of the leukemia diagnosis he received while he was a junior at the University of Michigan: “You ask yourself, why me? My mother was convinced it was the fraternity house I lived in.” Dr. Leonard then spoke about why young adult cancer diagnoses are sometimes missed. He explained that typical symptoms like fatigue, weight change, and pain in the body aren’t immediately attributed to cancer, as they would be in elderly patients. Moreover, young adults, or patients between the ages of 15 and 39, face unique challenges when undergoing treatment. During Dr. Viny’s own cancer journey, he didn’t think to ask about how treatment would affect his sperm count until the moment when his chemo had just been mixed; and so the doctors “whisked [him] down to the shameful basement area, where there was a plastic-covered loveseat, a plastic cup, and a playboy from 1992.” But now, Dr. Viny attested, “the darkest day of my life is linked to the two brightest days of my life: the days my 2 daughters were born.” Despite the humor Dr. Leonard and Dr. Viny infused their speeches with, they were serious about their fundraising and research mission. When the emcee from Columbia asked, “Which one of you guys is funnier, and why is it Dr. Viny?” Dr. Leonard replied, “We’re all on the same team, fighting cancer.” They brought the audience back to the core reason for the event being hosted: to raise money and awareness for cancer research.

Before the final performance of the night, the presenters played a video recorded by Nick Kroll to apologize for the advertised headliner Malik Elassal cancelling at the last minute. Through the camera, Kroll admitted, “I’m not there because, well, no one was gonna pay me.” He reminded us, “Spoiler alert, Malik BAILED”—but, he insisted, he got us someone else just as great. This guy is one of the top ten comedians to watch: “He’s got a mustache like Malik, but he’s his own man.”

Indeed, he did have a mustache just like Malik. Josh Ocean Thomas, a New York-based comedian you’ve probably seen on Instagram Reels, jumped onto the stage. “I went to Columbia,” he proclaimed, to huge applause—“College Chicago.” Thomas told us stories about his parents and what it was like to grow up biracial: “My mom’s a devout Muslim, she prays five times a day, that’s a bunch…” His dad, on the other hand, smokes weed and does yoga. Malik asked him recently how he thinks the universe was created, to which his father (taking a drag of his blunt) replied, “I didn’t do it.” His parents sat in the crowd, and it was wildly entertaining to see their reactions when he pointed them out. Malik then talked about his life as a cruise ship tour guide, his childhood years at Catholic school, and his college experiences. Thomas’ approach was deeply personal and felt easy to connect with. He was engaging and made spontaneous jokes directed at those in the front row (including Nick Kroll’s brother). In typical Lerner fashion, random music blared from another room, which Thomas addressed: “They’re having a better time in there. Is there a party behind this wall?” All the comedians were great, but it was clear Thomas was the professional. He constantly kept the energy high, and it was a great way to end the event. 

This event encompassed many things, but kept its purpose at the core of it. Although very entertaining, it was equally informative and did not hesitate to remind us of its purpose of raising funding for cancer research. We appreciated the organizers’ dedication and how fun it was for the audience to interact with the performers. Catfight was competitive, fun, hilarious, and remained true to its cause.

Image via Author