On Friday, November 13, Publisher Sydney Kaufman attended opening night of Columbia University Players’ production of Do You Feel Anger? in the Lerner Blackbox. Content warnings for brief discussions of sexual violence/harassment.

This past weekend, Columbia University Players (CUP) performed their rendition of Do You Feel Anger?, directed by Emerson Antunes-Black (BC ’28), stage managed by Quinn Fastnow (CC ’28), and tech directed by Aida Kasparova (CC ’29). The show ran for three performances across November 13 and 14 in the Austin E. Quigley Blackbox in Lerner Hall. Written in 2016, Mara Nelson-Greenberg’s thought-provoking play Do You Feel Anger? asks its audience important questions, such as: “How can one stand up to systemic misogynistic oppression amidst a culture that seeks to silence its opposition?” and “Can people who refuse to change be held accountable?” and… “What?” 

The play follows empathy coach Sofia (Natalie Jones, BC ’29) as she attempts to teach empathy to the employees of a debt-collection agency: the physically aggressive Howie (Ava Paris Lattimore, CC ’27), the proto-performative male Jordan (Zyaire Gale, CC ’27), and the seemingly absent-minded Eva (Addison Calhoun, BC ’30). The company also includes their supervisor Jon (Jonathan Zecena, GS ’28) and coworker Janie (Janine Rho, GS ’28), who spends the entire play hiding in the women’s bathroom. Amidst all this, Sofia avoids phone calls from her mother (also played by Rho) after learning that her father has a second family via an email that he sent her.

At the beginning of the show, Eva is entrenched in this satirized boys’ club culture, desperately searching for a boyfriend, any boyfriend, to avoid being harassed by the men at the office. She’s being serially mugged by an unknown assailant in the office kitchen, a problem  Jon claims to be on top of but never does anything about (this is an unsubtle allegory for sexual assault). In uncomfortable situations, she blurts out increasingly absurd and morbid confessions (including eating—not absorbing—her twin in utero). When Eva breaks up with her awful and ridiculous 130-year-old boyfriend (Jamie Treatman-Clark, CC ’27), he makes a hilarious but unsuccessful attempt to blow up the building in order to punish her. Calhoun expertly navigated Eva’s arc of breaking away from the cognitive dissonance that allowed her to accept her mistreatment only for her to fall into helplessness as she feels she cannot change it. She laudably grounds her character within her circumstances while infusing a doe-eyed naïveté that enables the audience to really believe her ditzy mannerisms and state of denial toward her coworkers’ behavior.

Sofia, as an outsider, pushes back against the office’s culture at first, encouraging Eva to stand up for herself. Over the course of the play, she slowly begins to capitulate to the mind-numbing and male-dominated environment by babying the men and laughing at their offensive jokes. Jones commendably portrays the slippery slope that one finds themself on when they let small offenses slide, in this case in the name of “getting through” to Jordan and Howie. Jones’ performance conveys the emotional impact of Sofia’s choices and her betrayal of Eva, making the audience feel the full weight of what she loses with every concession while still understanding why she makes each one.

Eventually, Eva has enough of the way she is treated in the office and seeks refuge in the bathroom after an outburst that leaves her labeled as “crazy” by her male coworkers (a moniker previously applied to Janie) while Sofia’s support continually diminishes. Jon pressures Sofia throughout the play to finish her empathy training early, culminating in his signing the completion form for her when she continues to refuse. He, Howie, and Jordan begin circling her in a shark-like manner while attempting to extort sexual acts from her before she, too, has a “crazy” outburst in self-defense and runs to hide in the bathroom with the other women. 

The play, up until this point, has toed the line between reality and hyperbole, with the male employees being unable to comprehend (or pronounce) words like “nervous” or even the “empathy” (which they believe to be some kind of bird) that their training revolves around, while also weaponizing the therapy speak they do pick up against their female peers with full seriousness. Here, it takes a full turn into the surreal, with the women’s bathroom becoming a sacred liminal space in which Janie, Eva, and Sofia can be safe. Eva and Janie sync their bleeding—not that kind, but the blood from their actual injuries—and Eva is able to become a mermaid (her ideal form). The shift is best reflected by the lighting, designed by Meredith Rouse (CC ’30), which changes from the harsh overhead LEDs of the conference room to a dimmer, moodier blueish-gray. Sofia sees the literal blood on her hands from her complicity as Janie directly explains to her (and the audience) how misogynistic micro-aggressions build up over time and how calling them out gets women labeled as “the problem.” The play ends with Sofia finally calling her mother.

It is almost always bad form to discuss one’s own assessment of the original material in the review of a production. The play has been so thoroughly described above, though, because it’s important for the reader to understand this writer’s position on it in order to fully appreciate this review. Much of the comedy of Do You Feel Anger? is grating (though that is a subjective criticism), the messaging is confused at best (seeming to suggest that the onus of societal sexism is on the women who do not stand up to misogyny rather than on the men who violently perpetuate it), and the playwright doesn’t appear to trust the viewer to understand the show’s themes without spelling them out explicitly (with Janie’s soapboxing being only one of two or three instances where the play really beats the audience over the head with something it had already shown many times prior). While the  analysis of the original material is irrelevant to the actual review, it illustrates the impressiveness of this production in making the show not only watchable but legitimately brilliant.

The show takes great strides in elevating the humor to its maximum potential. Visual gags, such as a phone cord from Jon’s desk that slowly reaches a comically improbable length over the course of a call in which he discovers the existence of periods, and physical comedy, such as Jordan standing to slam the conference room table with his leg when sharing his “poetry,” earned huge laughs from the audience. The use of the space is unlike any other student production attended by yours truly, with the set extending between the seating sections and actors continuing to perform on either side of the audience when they aren’t onstage.

With an unprecedented number of assistant directors—Margaret Graham (BC ’30), Adrien Honig (CC ’30), Sophie Obstfeld (CC ’30), and Josselyn Wolf (BC ’30)—one might expect the effect to be that of too many cooks in the proverbial kitchen, but the opposite was true. Even the blocking was highly innovative; though seated in the left section of the Blackbox, this writer was able to see at least as much of the show as one expects to see from the center section. Perhaps more, given the number of scenes in which Howie, Eva, and/or Jordan sit with their backs to the center audience. This was, however, potentially to the detriment of those who chose the center section, as they missed the characters’ facial acting in these moments. The offstage activities that take place in the sets in the wings also are each only viewable to maybe 25% of the audience at a time. 

This writer was unable to see anything that happened at Jon’s desk, but had a very good view of the office kitchen. Viewers who could not see the kitchen missed watching one of Eva’s muggings, after which she lays unconscious for several minutes without any help, an event that doesn’t exactly seem like it should be withheld from so much of the audience. However, one must account for the limitations of the space itself. Having 25% of the audience able to see these moments is definitely better than not staging them at all. The fact that so many well-crafted performances run simultaneously throughout the show is itself a tremendous accomplishment.

All of the show’s design enhanced the world of the office, especially the costume designs of Sophie Fernandez (BC ’30) and Lily Siris (BC ’30). The women’s outfits evolve with each new appearance, most notably those of Sofia and Eva. Sofia begins the play in pants and a blouse, much to the dismay of the men in the office, who all ask her to wear a dress. During her final entrance into the conference room, she arrives in a skirt to demonstrate her character regression. Conversely, Eva wears old-fashioned dresses to the office, until her final work outfit, which consists of a shirt, cardigan, and pair of slacks. The contrast between the colors of Eva and Sofia’s costumes, with Sofia in muted pinks and Eva in bright teal, reflects the contrast in their roles as the story develops. None of the men in the show ever change costumes, for the characters never change internally either.

On the whole, the sound, designed by Eshan Kabir (CC ’27), and lights subtly punctuate the thematic developments of each scene, with flickers and droning at appropriate moments. There’s a really excellent gag where the old man cracks his back alongside a well-timed sound effect. The only critique that can be offered here is that the droning became intrusive at certain moments when it completely drowned out what the actors were saying.

It would be remiss not to give special credit to the set, created by Laura Ziessler (BC ’27) and Zlata Korishkova (BC ’29), as it rivaled that of professional productions in terms of quality and realism. The onstage set consisted of a sizable conference table, complete with a whiteboard and uniform rolling chairs, and a wall with two functional doors and office blinds. The blinds are only raised in the final scene, where they reveal the interior of the women’s bathroom, which featured two actual stalls and a porcelain-looking sink. Ziessler also designed remarkable props, including a genuinely jaw-dropping bird made of Post-It notes that flies over the audience when Howie and Jordan “solve” empathy.

All in all, CUP’s Do You Feel Anger? is an excellent production and a shining example of the heights student theatre can achieve. With a strong and well-cast roster of actors, coupled with a clearly dedicated production team, it far surpasses its original script. You feel content because you saw this show, is that right?

Header and bird image via the author