Connect with us

All Articles

ESC Describes All The Ways Columbia Is Awful And All The Solutions Columbia Hasn’t Undertaken


“We eagerly await action from the central administration, and we hope and pray that our efforts may help save the lives of our peers, colleagues, and friends.”

This week’s ESC meeting was a continuation of last week’s discussion that attempted to find ways to alleviate the stress of Columbia students. While the Columbia Administration acknowledged the Executive Vice President Sidney Perkins ideas, it remains uncertain if the administration will take student proposals into consideration. 

Yesterday’s weekly meeting of the Engineering Student Council quickly established itself as a spiritual continuation of last week’s meeting, with Executive Vice President for Policy Sidney Perkins first detailing the results of last week’s poignant resolution. VP Perkins recounted how the University Senate reached out to ESC after the Senate’s Student Affairs Committee (SAC) published a private memorandum regarding mental health conditions on campus. ESC was asked to provide an addendum to this private memorandum, prompting ESC’s Policy Committee to perform quite a bit of outreach in the compilation of a 10 page document.

The Addendum, which VP Perkins explained “should be entirely public,” consisted of suggestions “to prevent and respond to such tragedies on campus.” The preface to the document (linked here and included below) heralds how “no student should ever feel that their only escape from the pressures and stresses of Columbia is to be found in death,” and identifies three areas where “suicide prevention” intersects with “student wellness”: exorbitant student academic stress, a lack of student spaces dedicated to mindfulness and identity, and widespread feelings of student isolation.

The document comments upon a litany of improvements to campus life which have been haphazardly and separately thrown about by various student populations in recent history. The breadth of the recommendations, each reinforced with numerical data or the successful policies of peer institutions, is quite staggering in retrospect. ESC identifies faults in the bureaucratic and inefficient Center for Student Advising, negligible faculty-student rapport, the lack of student spaces, the absence of a 24/7 student union, ill conceived NSOP programming, and the University’s inability to internally handle the mental health situation at Columbia. Recommendations vary just as wildly, ranging from the expansion of prefrosh orientation programs like COÖP and CUE, the provision of greater resources for students with children, the opening of Lerner as a redesigned student union after the evacuation of the administrative Mecca to Uris (or vice-versa), and miscellaneous steps to help mend Columbia’s campus community in the wake of tragedy. In grim fashion, the Addendum concludes with ESC’s statement that “We eagerly await action from the central administration, and we hope and pray that our efforts may help save the lives of our peers, colleagues, and friends.” The full text of the private memorandum, as well as the various addenda (including ESC’s addendum), will shortly—and physically—arrive in President Bollinger’s hands.

Otherwise, the rest of the discussion this week was based around a more defined version of last week’s constitutional amendment proposal by VP Perkins to institute what are defined as “continuing resolutions.” Such resolutions would essentially hold future councils to described goals, bounded by expiry dates within 10 years of a continuing resolution’s passage. Passing a continuing resolution would then require a 2/3 majority of the council, whereas a continuing resolution would require a 1/3 plurality to absolve the council of its responsibility to the outlined goals. Responsibility, determined as consisting of regular reports as well as demonstrated effort, is assigned to a specific position in the text of the resolution, and that position’s accrued responsibilities will pass on to the position’s next representative. VP Perkins, in response to some questioning on this point, clarified that this might put some undue effort on candidates with no personal interest in these issues assuming such responsibilities, but counterbalanced this by pointing out how a candidate could run on eliminating ESC’s subjugation to that specific continuing resolution. Therefore, VP Perkins advocated, if a 2/3 majority were unwilling to impeach a refractory council member (as a 2/3 majority is required for impeachment), then that member’s “responsibilities” would not inherently be supported. While transference of responsibility was brought up, nothing concrete was described by VP Perkins.


  • ESC is trying to set up a student formal of some sort in the near future in partnership with SGA. Apparently, they reached out to CCSC, but that council allegedly did not want to be involved with this activity or partnership.
  • ESC has a functioning (and efficacious, apparently) suggestion box on its website. A single suggestion has been received so far, relating to mental health on campus. But ESC is waiting for recommendations and is, demonstrably, paying attention.
  • In response to ESC’s proposal for a printer in Carleton Commons, Dean Brovman reportedly replied that “the question about need for printers specifically in Carleton Commons is an open one.” This is a mystifying response given ESC’s survey denoting a vast majority of students as desiring a printer in this space. Dean Brovman will be presented with these data soon.

Write a comment

Your email address will not be published.



  • Anonymous says:

    @Anonymous What has compounded the issue, but will be improving over the next few years, is basically the entirety of Barnard Colleges 2800 students on Columbia’s campus 24/7 because of their lack of a library, student spaces, study spaces, computer spaces, gym, pool, grass, etc, and the delay in starting construction of the business school two new buildings that were supposed to be complete in 2019, but will not be complete until 2021. But as each new building opens in Manhattanville, space will open on Morningside. Freeing up Uris for the college will be extremely helpful.

    1. Hey CU Admin says:

      @Hey CU Admin what the fuck does this have to do with kids killing themselves? Stop evading … #KickBollingersAss

  • Here's a proposal: says:

    @Here's a proposal: Strip and flog each and every senior columbia administrator on low plaza, then tar and feather bollinger and run him and his ugly wife out of town.

    You’re welcome

  • Youngweon Lee says:

    @Youngweon Lee finn i’m not the tuesday daily

  • Have Your Say

    Where are you going this summer?

    View Results

    Loading ... Loading ...

    Recent Comments

    Step one. Please tell students to respect public safety officers and security. They work very hard and deserve respect. (read more)
    Barnard Fires Executive Director of Public Safety, Not Involved Officers, Following Milstein Center Assault
    August 18, 2019
    Don’t act dumb. A responsible victim would go to the police, not the halls of academia, if there were a (read more)
    Barnard Fires Executive Director of Public Safety, Not Involved Officers, Following Milstein Center Assault
    August 18, 2019
    Most crimes on campus are students sexually assaulting other students. Y'all just don't get Clery Alerts about that so you (read more)
    Barnard Fires Executive Director of Public Safety, Not Involved Officers, Following Milstein Center Assault
    August 17, 2019