Our Magnificent Muckraker Sarah Ngu and Graphics God Stephen Davan have teamed up to dissect CCSC’s fall budget. Bwog is holding student government accountable like never before.
Update (10/11): CCSC has put together an informational video with VP Kevin of Funding Kevin Zhai, to explain exactly where CCSC’s money comes from, and where it goes.
Kevin Zhai, VP of Funding, is probably the most exciting player now on the Student Council scene — that might not be saying much, but his proposals to rethink everything about student group funding are groundbreaking and, to some, unsettling.
Last Sunday, Zhai explained the process of funding and then opened the floor for discussion on how to best allocate funds in an “ideal world” (if that sounds like Plato’s Republic, Zhai is a philosophy major). From comments made by council members, this was the first time that many of them heard how money is actually allocated to student groups.
Here’s how student group funding at Columbia works:
Every Columbia student is billed $651 a semester for a “Student Life Fee.” $105 of that goes to Columbia College Student Council. CCSC keeps a bit of the money, and allocates the rest. Barnard, SEAS and GS all do the same, but CCSC has, by far, the largest amount of money.
Open questions:
While CCSC decides the budgets of groups that promote student life, it also puts on its own events that promote… student life. The council essentially decides how much money to give itself. Should CCSC instead be treated as one vote among many and invite all the relevant players—the governing boards who oversee all clubs on campus—to the table so that everyone can collectively decide how to split up funds? Or should it be viewed as the main body responsible for student life which delegates to governing boards to handle the details?
The immediate concern is what CCSC is going to do with that enormous $101k surplus, and $79k for discretionary spending (see infographic above). Council traditionally has tens of thousands of dollars in surplus, but $101k is unusually high. This is likely a result of low spending of late, as no new sources of funding have been announced.
Stay tuned:
Bwog will be publishing a series of articles breaking down the allocation of that 61.69% of the budget allocated to club governing boards—a diverse array of recipients, ranging from Community Impact to Greek life—and asking the questions: Were their allocations fair? Are these decisions in the best interest of the entire student body?
48 Comments
@Tea Party I think we should abolish student council and take back our university.
@Tea party Can we get some lower taxes up in here?
I’m serious. I dont believe that most people get their money’s worth.
@cc 13 i dont know what free class t-shirts everyone’s talking about. we have to pay for ours
@ryan everyone pays for their class t-shirts.
@Anonymous Wait, so part of my student life fee goes to the councils of the three colleges I don’t attend? I don’t mind my money going to fund clubs I’m not a part of, but it kind of bugs me that it’s being used for stuff that doesn’t impact me.
@sarah ngu No, the part of your student life fee that goes to Council goes to the Council of your college (CC, BC, ESC, GS).
Councils do pool their money to contribute to the governing boards which oversee all clubs on campus, in a process called F@CU.
@Oh, Lawds Honestly, my high school student council had more to show for themselves than these junior bureaucrats. Then again, I do appreciate the weekly Havana Central advertisement that “Senior Underground” (lulz) sends out.
@Oh, Lawds Honestly, my high school student council had more to show for themselves than these junior bureaucrats. Then again, I do appreciate the weekly Havana Central advertisement that “Senior Underground” (lulz) sends me.
@Anonymous 80,000 is a lot to be undecided about
@CCSC Most (if not all) of that goes to co-sponsorships, i.e. events for which the student groups go directly to CCSC, asking for extra money outside of their budget.
@unemployed CC'11 they can give it to me.
@Anonymous Super Splendid Statement!
@Lucky Sarah + Stephen = Dream Team
@Anonymous Are you saying that you don’t profit from the money you have invested? You are not a member of any student club? You don’t use Lerner (as a whole)? The computer labs? The printing quota? The New York Times? The free lectures? The free museum admissions? The events in Roone/Party Space? The class T-shirts? Projectors in classroom? The machines in Dodge? Butler’s books? Cubmail’s webspace? The bathrooms?
Cause if you’re not, I’ll personally give the money back to you.
@Just saying... I’d pay a few extra dollars to switch to gmail and not have to use Cubmail’s webspace…
@Anonymous I use a few of those things, but for $600 I could easily find better alternatives
@Anonymous no you couldn’t bro.
@Anonymous I didn’t know clubs spent so much money on the computer labs, projectors in classrooms, library books, and bathroom maintenance.
@RR No, but that’s where most of the student life fee goes. Only $105 (or less) of the $650 goes to clubs.
@Anonymous … can I have my student life fee back?
@bschool the business school method? Clubs fund themselves. If you want to join a club, you have to pay dues to get on their mailing lists? The free market decides. That way, clubs which are popular survive and thrive. Those that aren’t, don’t.
@... inb4 shitstorm
@Anonymous What about students who don’t have the money to pay dues but want to participate in an extracurricular activity? As it stands, CCSC can dole out money based on which clubs they feel do the most meaningful activities/ need the most money to sustain themselves/ have shown the best results in the past. If clubs were funded by students, they would focus on recruiting in more members and generating funds, drawing attention away from whatever activities they should be focused on.
@I think that’s compensated by the fact that the bschool doesnt charge the $651 student life fee, or if they do, it’s way reduced. that way, students can allocate their own expenses based on their preferences. my bro who went to the b-school spent maybe $400 a year on his 10 clubs. it cuts out a layer of overhead (read: CCSC) and makes things more efficient.
btw, I trust the individual club member way more than I trust the perenially renewed policy wonks of CCSC to allocate club monies. you’re damn right clubs that were funded by students would have a fire lit under their respective asses to attract members — as they should. they would also spend the money they get far more wisely, bc their funding levels are directly dependent on their members’ satisfaction.
@Anonymous agreed! also, I would maybe leave the current amount to remain factored in to financial aid, so that students on a full ride could still afford clubs if the fees got more expensive.
@GS nationalist Mentioning the GS budget is indeed helpful.
@wait, sooo i always see ccsc kids sporting “ccsc” embazoned jackets and tshirts…and then i realize they don’t pay for them. that’s where my monies are going? are you kidding me?
@Anonymous Your class T shirts are paid for by the same fund…
@CCSC Class shirts, college days shirts, homecoming shirts…. you don’t have any of those? :)
@Anonymous I don’t! And like, honestly, I’d rather people pay for their own shirts, and I get to keep my $600/semester or whatever.
@lol jackets?!
@Nope Columbia College shirts are paid for by students sometimes with subsidies sometimes without. CCSC hasn’t had shirts since 2009 and they were paid for by CCSC members. No jackets at all to my knowledge
@Anonymous why do sophomore get more money than juniors?
@CCSC The money is allocated based on a budget proposal made by each class council. So if 2013 wants to do something like Potterpalooza again, they’d get more money.
@yourCCSC new feature! send CCSC an anonymous messages or suggestions by going to yourCCSC.com and hitting ‘talk to CCSC’ in the top left corner
@yourCCSC leave ccsc anonymous feedback/questions/comments by going to http://yourccsc.com/ and hitting ‘talk to ccsc’ in the top left
@Kevin Zhai is a sexy beast! :D
@Anonymous this is outrageous.
@CCSC What is? Let us know!
@CC '12 Give it to Bacchanal.
@seconded Bacchanal does it best
@Obviously into Club Sports!!!!!
@CC'09 Let’s do it like bush and give that surplus back as a rebate check! Then we can borrow money to liberate NYU.
@Why are we charged an elevator fee? How retarded is that?
@Anonymous Please don’t use that word that way.
@Why are we charged an elevator fee? How Down Syndrome is that?
@Anonymous my aunt is mentally handicapped, but I don’t feel bad using the word retarded. It’s not even a term used to refer to mentally handicapped people anymore–it’s essentially lost its original meaning. It’s like using the word “dumb”–you’re not being offensive to people who can’t speak because the word has been entirely reappropriated at this point.
@Anonymous Cause we use them.