Connect with us

All Articles

LectureHop: Aquinas and Suffering

Bwog Guide to the Weekend Editor Sara Jane Panfil attended last night’s 2008 Thomas Merton Lecture about “The Problem of Evil in the Thought of St. Thomas Aquinas.” Justify your midterms anguish with Aquinas!

There’s no better time than midterms time to ponder the meaning and existence of human suffering.  After all, it doesn’t seem to make much sense, logically, that an omniscient, omnipotent, perfectly good God would allow us mortals to undergo such strife.  Especially when you’re a medieval Christian philosopher like St. Thomas Aquinas.

Luckily, Thomas Aquinas was a clever guy.  He outlined two criteria for human suffering: humans suffer when we are not able to be who we “ought” to be—when we’re not able to realize our full potentiality—and when we are kept from the desires of our hearts.  Physical pain, the obvious candidate for a definition of suffering, isn’t a necessary component.  After all, there are different kinds of physical pain, and not all of them are bad.   

But no matter your kind of suffering, don’t despair, says Aquinas: there is indeed a morally sufficient reason that God allows for human agony.  The lecturer, Professor Eleanor Stump of Saint Louis University, explained it eloquently, invoking the technical and precise language of philosophy, the authority of anecdotal evidence, and referencing the overlapping research and practices common to the modern psychological and medical communities.  In short (since the entire program took a bit over an hour and a half), God allows us to suffer because it brings us closer to our full potential and to the desires of our heart, even if it doesn’t seem that way at first.   

Now of course, since this is Christian philosophy, this is a theodicy that requires consistent Christian paradigms.  Professor Stump found herself repeating this premise in the question-and-answer portion when people still weren’t convinced that there exist “good” reasons to suffer.  She also made the point—which she ended up repeating in the Q&A—that Thomas Aquinas, or indeed any philosophy about suffering, is never sufficient to explain suffering away.  We, as feeling human beings first and foremost, must always give suffering its proper respect, and must always use our mortal powers to actively counter-act or prevent it.  A philosophy about the utility of suffering, no matter how convincing, should never excuse us from taking action against it. 

Overall, the good-sized crowd gathered in St. Paul’s Chapel received her lecture well.  Granted, it was a lecture of limited scope (Thomas Aquinas wrote prolifically, and the contingent nature of suffering provides infinite avenues of challenge), but certainly worked well as a concise summary on the topic.  Thomas Aquinas has created a flexible philosophy on this and many other subjects.  Professor Stump encouraged those in attendance to expand it; with all the different kinds of heartbreak and woe in the world, it makes for a worthy challenge.       

Click to show comments

Write a comment

Your email address will not be published.



  • hahaha says:

    @hahaha Bwog should tag more posts with :Suffering

  • sad religion major says:

    @sad religion major ugggghhhhhhhh i missed one of the few chances to learn something about christianity on this freaking campus.

  • well-wrtten says:

    @well-wrtten great review – easy to follow – made it seem like a dece. event.

  • bklyn says:

    @bklyn ahhhhhhhh would luv 2 go but babysitting!!!!!!

  • Todd P says:

    @Todd P Hey kids! Midterms bogging you down? CMJ not doing it for you this year? I’m bringing the party back to Lionville all this week. We’ve got lots lined up at the usual suspects (ADP and Lerner Party Space). It all kicks off tonight. And it’s free and presented with love by Todd P!

    TONIGHT at ADP – CMJamb with performances by CRYSTAL STILTS, VIOLENS, Holy Ghost, CHAIRLIFT, and a super secret guest we can’t even put on here. The party gets rocking at 8pm. BYOB, please!

    TOMORROW at ADP – MIDNIGHT MANIA. That’s right. We’re doing MIDNIGHT MANIA at Lerner Party Space even if the basketball team won’t. Come check out THE MAE SHI, Pela, Fiasco, and VIVIAN GIRLS. Doors at 11. Gotta keep it quiet to keep security at bay.

    THURSDAY at LERNER PARTY SPACE – Super All Day Party presented by Rack & Soul. Ponytail, HIGH PLACES, Matt & Kim, and others. Show starts at noon!

    Put down the books and join the party!

    -Todd P

  • bwog says:

    @bwog way too many lecturehops. we already go to enough lectures.

  • Ad

    Have Your Say

    What should Bwog's new tagline be?

    View Results

    Loading ... Loading ...

    Recent Comments

    Too much passive voice in this piece. (read more)
    An Announcement From Bwog’s Board
    October 23, 2020
    Yes I feel like there always is (read more)
    An Announcement From Bwog’s Board
    October 23, 2020
    LOL what? You are bwog, you are the New York Post of Columbia University news. I don't think any (read more)
    An Announcement From Bwog’s Board
    October 22, 2020
    People will always find something to be unhappy with even when progress is being made. It seems that Bwog is (read more)
    An Announcement From Bwog’s Board
    October 22, 2020

    Comment Policy

    The purpose of Bwog’s comment section is to facilitate honest and open discussion between members of the Columbia community. We encourage commenters to take advantage of—without abusing—the opportunity to engage in anonymous critical dialogue with other community members. A comment may be moderated if it contains:
    • A slur—defined as a pejorative derogatory phrase—based on ethnicity, race, gender, sexual orientation, ability, or spiritual belief
    • Hate speech
    • Unauthorized use of a person’s identity
    • Personal information about an individual
    • Baseless personal attacks on specific individuals
    • Spam or self-promotion
    • Copyright infringement
    • Libel
    • COVID-19 misinformation