Connect with us

All Articles

Stiglitz Speaks at Occupy Wall Street

Yesterday, our very own Professor Joseph Stiglitz, Nobel laureate for economics, stopped by Zuccotti Park to talk to the protestors, along with fellow economist Jeff Madrick. Because the demonstrators are not allowed to amplify sound in any way, the speeches are repeated a sentence at a time by the crowd so that the words can reach those who are not in earshot. Stiglitz’s opened his speech with a quip about the so-called echo chamber: “I realize the pedagogy of having to repeat what I say is very valuable, but it makes the whole process much longer.” Spoken like a true economist!

“There’s a system where we socialize losses and privatize gains,” he continued. “That’s not capitalism, that’s not a market economy, that’s a distorted economy and if we continue with that we won’t succeed in growing, and we won’t succeed in creating a just society.” This obviously went down well with the crowd, and Prof Stiglitz appeared to be very chuffed. Watch the full speech, or read our transcript below:

Joseph Stiglitz:
Before talking about economics, I want to say something about democracy. In July, I was in Spain, talking to the “indignados” there, the protesters. There, I could use a bullhorn. I didn’t have to go through this echo chamber. I realize the pedagogy of having you repeat what I say is very valuable, but it makes the whole process much longer. The fact that you are not allowed to use a megaphone on a Sunday is outrageous! We have too many regulations stopping democracy and not enough regulations stopping Wall Street from misbehaving. You should have the right peacefully and demonstrate your views and not be arrested and not be sprayed with pepper spray.

So now I want to talk a little bit about what I said in Spain, and then about the banks. The protests there are called the “indignados,” and I said, “You are right to be indignant.” The fact is, the system is not working right. It is not right that we have so many people without jobs when we have so many needs that we have to fulfill. It’s not right that we are throwing people out of their houses when we have so many homeless people.

Our financial markets have an important role to play. They’re supposed to allocate capital and manage risk, but they’ve misallocated capital and created risk. We are bearing the cost of their misdeeds. There’s a system where we’ve socialized losses and privatized gains. That’s not capitalism! That’s not a market economy. That’s a distorted economy, and if we continue with that, we won’t succeed in growing, and we won’t succeed in creating a just society.

Jeff Madrick:
To make it a little more clear how Wall Street was allowed to take all that risk, the bankers were able to take home their bonuses every year by developing risky strategies that one day had to go bad. They knew, however, they would take out their money before most of those investments went bad. Economists call this “asymmetric incentives.” You make money by taking risk, but nobody takes it away from you when the strategies don’t work and lose lots of money. That was one of the core problems with Wall Street. Could Washington have done something about that? Yes! There were other problems. I’ve got to throw it to Joe to talk about other problems.

One of the things the banks did was to prey on the poorest Americans [through predatory lending. We knew about it. There were some people who tried to stop it, but they used their political power, [that is] Wall Street used its political power, to stop those who would stop them.

Just to keep going on this, the FBI actually told the powers that be that there was an epidemic of fraud in 2004 in the mortgage market. Washington and the Federal Reserve had the power to do something about that. They did not. The more bad mortgages went on, the predatory lending got worse, and the powers that be—in particular and let me name names, Alan Greenspan, the Chairman of the Federal Reserve—was able to retire in glory. Is there something with this picture? There sure is, and there are a lot of other areas we can discuss.

Two more things. After the bubble broke, they continued in their way of disobeying the law, in a sense—throwing people out of their houses, even in some cases when they didn’t owe money. The balance of rights has been distorted. We bailed out the banks with an understanding that there would be a restoration of lending. All there was was a restoration of bonuses! Unless we deal with the anti-competitive practices, with the reckless lending and speculative behavior, with the anti-competitive practices, unless we restore finance to the function it should serve, we won’t have a robust recovery.

One last point. There had been few civil suits by the federal government. Even when they make them, they settle. There may be some hope somebody’s lighting a fire under prosecutors and attorneys general. Not all on Wall Street broke the law, but it is hard to believe that some didn’t, and it’s important so that all of us can understand that not all that happened was simply well-meaning gigantic errors. By prosecuting where there was serious unethical practices, we may provide another deterrent. Unethical practices were a major contributor, in my view, to the crisis we had and the difficult future we face.

Write a comment

Your email address will not be published.



  • Spellcheck says:

    @Spellcheck I believe “Zuccotti” is spelled with two c’s and “occupy” with a y (in the tags).

    1. Claire says:

      @Claire I believe you are correct.

  • Anonymous says:

    @Anonymous Penn Badgley in the grey hoodie. around 4:05 ?

    1. Anonymous says:

      @Anonymous You’re right. You’re seriously right. Hilarious.

    2. mmmm says:

      @mmmm i may risk getting arrested in order to tap that.

  • Anonymous says:

    @Anonymous After listening to the repetition of Stiglitz’s speech by the crowd, all I can hear are the sounds from outside my EC single echoing in my head. Over and over and over again.

  • boh says:

    @boh seriously, a real OG right therrrrr

  • Anonymous says:

    @Anonymous OMG You’re right.

  • anon says:

    @anon the [inaudible] is “indignados” (i.e. “the indignant”), the name for the protesters in spain

    1. Peter says:

      @Peter ¡Muchas gracias!

  • van owen says:

    @van owen Hippies.

  • Anonymous says:

    @Anonymous Hopefully these issues will start to get more and more attention with people like Stiglitz and Madrick coming down to speak out.

  • Anonymous says:

    @Anonymous I hope many more Columbia professors will give lectures in the Wall Street

  • Trust nobody in power says:

    @Trust nobody in power Bush and Obama feel one in the same to me. Feels like the same crap different day, what makes politicians such liars about 90% of everything, I just don’t get it. Whatever happened to living with personal integrity or are we just a society of liars now. This country is depressing me, when’s the wall street/dc madness going to end. Neither party is the solution, it’s like they just pass the wall street ball to one another and play keep away against 99.9% of the rest of America.

  • Anonymous says:

    @Anonymous HE SHOULD RUN FOR PRESIDENT (what would “they” do to him if he tried??)

  • Anonymous says:

    @Anonymous i love joseph stiglitz

  • LeeMcD says:

    @LeeMcD Compelling and very funny video about unemployment and the economy, Obama, and Wall St…must see…

    Who’s Afraid of the Big Bad Bank?: An Uncensored Investigation of the U.S. Federal Reserve (Part 1 of an 8-Part Episode)…

    Also See: The Real Housewives of Tent City:

  • Have Your Say

    What should Bwog's new tagline be?

    View Results

    Loading ... Loading ...

    Recent Comments

    this is a sarah braner appreciation comment (read more)
    COMIC: Our Semester In One Image
    July 7, 2020
    is it too late to bully them into letting me take a gap year? :( (read more)
    Academic Calendar Updates, Pre-Orientation Programs Canceled Or Modified
    June 29, 2020
    This is great news Columbia is opening up on schedule. (read more)
    Academic Calendar Updates, Pre-Orientation Programs Canceled Or Modified
    June 25, 2020
    EXPEL ALL RACISTS FROM COLUMBIA! Tod Howard Hawks, Columbia College, Class of 1966 (read more)
    Racist Messages In FIJI GroupMe Surface, Involved Members Asked To Disaffiliate
    June 25, 2020

    Comment Policy

    The purpose of Bwog’s comment section is to facilitate honest and open discussion between members of the Columbia community. We encourage commenters to take advantage of—without abusing—the opportunity to engage in anonymous critical dialogue with other community members. A comment may be moderated if it contains:
    • A slur—defined as a pejorative derogatory phrase—based on ethnicity, race, gender, sexual orientation, ability, or spiritual belief
    • Hate speech
    • Unauthorized use of a person’s identity
    • Personal information about an individual
    • Baseless personal attacks on specific individuals
    • Spam or self-promotion
    • Copyright infringement
    • Libel