Connect with us

All Articles

BunsenBwog: A Matter Darkly

Each week, amateur astronomer Zach Kagan watches the skies for signs of SCIENCE. We present here this week’s findings—a special offering that highlights the search for dark matter.

Dark Matter is a term that’s thrown around a lot when people talk about unsolved mysteries in astrophysics. You’ve probably heard about the stuff, but you may not know what it is, which is fine because neither do the astrophysicists. The problem is that galaxies don’t rotate the way that they should. We predicted that outer stars should move much slower than inner cluster stars. However, they tend to move at similar velocities on the galaxy’s edge. That isn’t possible according to our understanding of gravity, so an explanation was developed: there must be much more mass in the galaxy than is observed. Much much more. Around 20 times more. And all that mass, which drives the rotation of outer stars, must completely be non-visible.

So what was this stuff? Two theories emerged. The first supposed that all this dark matter was made up of large, dim objects like black holes, rogue planets, and dense neutron stars. These objects were collectively called MACHOs (Massively Compact Halo Objects). The second theory supposed that dark matter was made up of Weakly Interacting Massive Particles, or WIMPs because scientists have a sense of humor too. Over time, as experiments found negative results for MACHOs, WIMPs became the popular theory for the nature of dark matter, even though no one was sure what WIMPs were anyway.

But WIMPs are elusive, as Columbia astrophysics professor Elena Aprile has found. Prof. Aprile led a team of scientists at Italy’s Gran Sasso laboratory on a 13 month search for the most promising WIMP candidates. The Columbia team built a sophisticated device called the XENON100, which uses ultra dense liquid Xenon to sense rare collisions with the faint WIMP particles. The device is brought deep—roughly 5,000 feet—underground in a chamber lined with copper and lead to filter out the hailstorm of particles we normally experience on the surface (such as cosmic and background radiation). However Aprile’s team didn’t find anything, not even after 225 full days of data gathering by XENON100.

That doesn’t mean that dark matter doesn’t exist. Certainly Prof. Aprile believes that dark matter is still out there because her team is building an even more sensitive instrument, the XENON1T, to try to observe weaker and weaker interactions between WIMPs and Xenon. And the majority of the physics academic community agrees with Prof. Aprile that dark matter exists in some form. But what that form is seems to be more and more mysterious. The only concrete evidence scientists have ever found for dark matter is in its gravitational effects on other masses. For example, when two galaxies colide (a bullet cluster in astronomy lingo) extra, non-observable mass seems to be affecting how the collision unfolds. There’s no radiation or particle interactions that give us an idea on what that mass might really be. That’s caused some physicists to develop theories for gravity that modify Newton’s gravitational equations to explain the problem of galatic rotation. But while Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MOND) and its variations do a good job of modeling galatic rotation, they don’t get us closer to understanding why they behave that way.

Dark matter has also retained support because of its usefulness in creating simulations of our cosmological history. A great example of this is study done by Eli Visbal and his Harvard team this summer. They created a mathematical model that predicts the development of early galaxies and clusters within a 1.3 billion lightyear cube of space. By filling this cube with dark matter, as well as the mixture of gasses that is known to be crucial for the creation of stars, the team was able to see that incipient galaxies formed around and within clumps of dark matter, while vast amounts of void would appear between galaxies. Visbal’s team determined that these dense, hot clouds of gas in the universe’s early proto-galaxies would would emit low radio signals, signals that we could theoretically measure from Earth. If such signals are found by a team of experimentalists then it would lend a lot of support to the dark matter theory.

Full disclosure: this Bwogger is hoping that it turns out that dark matter doesn’t exist. Why? The super scientific reason that  a certain bet was made with a certain suitemate freshman year…

Science via Wikimedia Commons

Write a comment

Your email address will not be published.



  • astroviewer says:

    @astroviewer Fermilab has installed a remarkable 570 megapixal “Dark Energy Camera” on the NSF Blanco telescope at Cerro Tololo Inter-American Observatory (CTIO) in Chile. It will survey 300 million galaxies and reveal repulsive movements due to dark energy. In time, we may know more of what’s happening out there.

  • Anonymous says:

    @Anonymous They found the Higgs Boson at Cern, or so some 6000 collaborators say – its one a a 300 million certainty. Well, that ain’t bad, though I haven’t a clue how it helps explain mass or gravity or that exotic stuff on “LOST.”

  • Cast Aspersion says:

    @Cast Aspersion Couldn’t we have a Xenon tank here in a deep US mine? Professor Elena Aprile enjoys living and working in Italy for the past ten years, the food and fashions are better there. However, wasn’t it the Italian Gran Sasso Laboratory that “discovered” faster than light neutrinos then backtracked with an announced equipment failure to explain the mistake. Something about our notion of Gravity is wrong. Is there an error with Mass and the Higgs particle, or the still undefined repulsion of Dark Energy , or some yet to be theorized multidimensional concept?

  • Tiny Tim says:

    @Tiny Tim Yada, yada, yada – the WISE infra-red survey has just found millions of dark objects: black holes, bizarre galaxies, and even stone-cold asteroids near Earth. So WIMPS may exist but MACHOS do too. Hell, I’ve met both on Campus. Who’s to say which prevail.

  • Anonymous says:

    @Anonymous Love BunsenBwog

  • Anonymous says:


  • Ad

    Have Your Say

    What should Bwog's new tagline be?

    View Results

    Loading ... Loading ...

    Recent Comments

    Why don't people dress like this anymore? (read more)
    Field Notes: ABBA Edition
    September 30, 2020
    Counterpoint: Have you actually eaten there? The point about the disappointing sushi is right on. (read more)
    If Columbia Dining Halls Were Reviewed By CULPA
    September 29, 2020
    Mayo is totally weird but it totally works, definitely seconding that tip. Ditto the lid, it helps melt the cheese (read more)
    CWB: Grilled Cheese
    September 29, 2020

    Comment Policy

    The purpose of Bwog’s comment section is to facilitate honest and open discussion between members of the Columbia community. We encourage commenters to take advantage of—without abusing—the opportunity to engage in anonymous critical dialogue with other community members. A comment may be moderated if it contains:
    • A slur—defined as a pejorative derogatory phrase—based on ethnicity, race, gender, sexual orientation, ability, or spiritual belief
    • Hate speech
    • Unauthorized use of a person’s identity
    • Personal information about an individual
    • Baseless personal attacks on specific individuals
    • Spam or self-promotion
    • Copyright infringement
    • Libel
    • COVID-19 misinformation