Connect with us

All Articles

Core Conditioning: The 118th Annual Varsity Show

Plz tr0ll b3low

Update: All the songs from the show are now available online.

When writing a show for an audience that consists of Columbia’s entire undergraduate population, basing the plot around the Core seems like choosing the easy route: It’s something that everyone can relate to, it provides cookie-cutter jokes and references, and it’s relatively low risk. It is, however, a path rife with the pitfalls of predictability and ennui. Yet V118 doesn’t just sidestep these obstacles, but leaps over them with sparkle and wit. It goes above and beyond; questioning and criticizing Columbia as opposed to merely parodying her. V118 takes a smartly written plot and executes it with passion and gusto, giving all of us a chance to self-deprecate and still leave with our pride intact.

The show’s strongest quality is undoubtedly its relevance. The Core, pre-professionalism, the validity and worth of a liberal arts education—these are things that matter to all of us as Columbians. They’re on our minds. Constantly. V118 manages to pick most of these issues apart, while still taking a tongue-in-cheek approach that keeps the audience laughing throughout the show.

While Act I ran the risk of dragging, the plot and character development were both engaging and well-paced. Instead of getting bogged down by a complicated web of storylines like V117, this year’s show centered around the conflict between Niamh (which is not pronounced Neeeeee-am) O’Brien (Rebekah Lowin CC’14) and her Corporate Core, and a Columbia student named Phineas (Sean Walsh CC’14) who seeks nothing more than the permanent sanctification of Columbia’s liberal arts curriculum. Though the ending arrived somewhat suddenly and was slightly off-kilter, the message was nothing if not earnest and left us feeling happy and proud to be Columbians.

The sharply written script, by John Goodwin and Jeff Stern, both CC’12, surrounded both Niamh and Phineas with a host of lovable sidekicks. Like the plot itself, some of them ran the risk of being overly predictable: Derek (Alessio Mineo CC’14), the brown-nosing, business-minded student who desperately seeks Niamh’s official career fair recommendation; Claire (Eleanor Bray BC’14), the M2M obsessed Barnard girl playing the part of the love interest; Lexi (Jenny Singer, BC ’15), the tabloid-following foil to Phineas’s bookwormish tendencies. Clever writing, songs composed for their already strong voices, and a variety of chuckle-worthy scenarios kept these characters from falling into the background. Most endearing was undoubtedly Deantini (Gray Henry CC’14), whose performance flawlessly channeled all of the Dean’s endearing quirks while still growing and developing alongside the rest of the cast.

V118’s central cast had consistently strong vocal performances, and the variety of vocal styles (Niamh’s operatic falsetto versus Deantini’s low drone) set up entertaining contrasts. Most of the musical numbers were smartly crafted and well executed—the Butler stacks anthem “Nothing But Love” was our personal favorite. However, the Koronet v. Famiglia themed “Natural Selection” was a bit too odd as its dancing pizza theme left the world of believability established in other scenes, and “The One Percent” left us feeling drab, with the exception of Deantini’s rather hilarious interlude. “Another Epic Day!” was a great opener, and “Poor Little Lass” and “Alma’s Army” were solidly enjoyable. At times the choreography wasn’t as strong as it could have been, as actors repeatedly faced spacing issues. On the whole, however, the musical numbers were high-quality, and whatever the show lacked in choreography it more than made up for with terrific set design.

The set design was representative of the brilliance of the writing and jokes—it was fundamentally strong, but it was the small touches that really brought it home, such as the sink in Phineas’s Wien single and the Sterling Cooper Draper Pryce sign at the career fair. Many of the punchlines followed this effective model: rather than try to work every scandal or significant event from the past year into the main plot, V118 instead distilled them into tremendously funny one-liners or asides (calling NoCo a “15-story coffee shop,” finding CUCR’s letter to Ahmadinejad in the stacks, working Obamanard into a breakup line). The show poked fun at other Ivies, Wall Street, and our own culture, predominantly with a strong dose of taste (jokes about GS and First Friday were probably the lone counterexamples).

With the end of the semester more or less here and finals looming, we recommend you set aside some time this weekend to see the Varsity Show. The plot is unabashedly Columbia College-centric (the sole mention of SEAS was a joke about Peña-Mora’s name), but the conflict between seeking knowledge and seeking employment is one every college student can relate to, especially come late spring. V118 gives us an opportunity to reflect lightheartedly on the past two semesters as well as Columbia’s overall culture, and this more critical approach, combined with hard-hitting jokes (the gym scene was incredibly apt, and a second use of the projector screen shortly before the finale had the audience in stitches) make for a great way to spend an evening. The core cast ran a little on the smaller side, but left little to be desired. Besides, we all know what happens when you get too many cooks in the kitchen…let’s just say that V118 is definitely Wilma.

This review represents the collective opinion of the Bwog staff and was authored by Brian Wagner

Write a comment

Your email address will not be published.



  • Alessio's physique says:

    @Alessio's physique can’t trump the sheer eargasm that is Geoff’s voice

    1. LOL says:

      @LOL It’s a good voice, but not all that special; he has an 80’s megamusical leading man voice.

      1. well says:

        @well you are simply wrong.

  • Scrotumface McGee says:

    @Scrotumface McGee It’s Irish.

  • Scrotumface McGee says:

    @Scrotumface McGee The slanderous use of my name was unforgivable.

  • Anonymous says:

    @Anonymous Best V-Show since 114. Just sayin. Also, apparently, if your show is good enough, the bwog comments are positive. Who knew?

  • John Goodwin Fan Club says:

    @John Goodwin Fan Club damn that boy can write… XMAS 4 was the best XMAS I’ve seen, and this was the best Varsity Show I’ve seen!

    Congrats to all involved, you deserve to be proud.

  • Anonymous says:

    @Anonymous did no one here get the derrick fu reference? “just cuz you have a building named after you, derek ph….ilosophy”

    1. Anonymous says:

      @Anonymous I missed it. I think the pause was far too subtle.

    2. woah woah woah says:

      @woah woah woah didn’t catch that… to think of all the other genius that probably slipped right over my head

    3. anon says:

      @anon i got it, but i didn’t realize he was at the level of a campus character to merit a parody, so i spent a lot of the show going, “… wait, are they really? no, they aren’t, but apparently yes”

  • Anonymous says:

    @Anonymous AH LOVED THE SHOW. So sad I watched it on the last night. Where can I buy the soundtrack!?

  • J.K. Rowling says:

    @J.K. Rowling the plot of V118 is eerily similar to Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix…

  • LOL Seriously? says:

    @LOL Seriously? Not one comment about the that gorgeous hunk of manflesh Alessio Mineo?

    1. I'm sorry but says:

      @I'm sorry but geoff is hotter

      1. Well says:

        @Well he’s certainly easy on the eyes. But for sheer beauty and raw sex appeal…no contest. Alessio.

      2. Not Patrick Aloia. I swear. says:

        @Not Patrick Aloia. I swear. What about Patrick, he was super attractive.

        1. Also so not Patrick at last FroSci lecture says:

          @Also so not Patrick at last FroSci lecture I agree. I felt very very hot for him. He was such a nugget, and certainly I’m not referring to his short stature this time.

          1. Anonymous says:

            @Anonymous Wait guys, I think Bwog’s tracking is broken, since you aren’t the same person at all! Thought I should let you know!

            1. Anonymous says:

              @Anonymous It’s okay, Patrick. Despite your nuggetty stature (which equates you subconsciously with my favorite McDonals chicken product), I think you’ve got it going on.

  • WOW says:

    @WOW JENNY SINGER (A.K.A LEXIE) IS SO FABULOUS, SO FIERCE AND GAVE A BRILLIANT PERFORMANCE. So, so impressed with the entire V118 cast!!!!!!!!!!!

  • disappointed says:

    @disappointed … it did not live up to the hype.

  • Anonymous says:

    @Anonymous Was anyone else disturbed by Koronets ethnic cleansing Famiglia?

    1. Never says:

      @Never has there been this much racism toward Italians in a Varsity Show since the off-kilter Sacco and Vanzetti parody from 1927, “Anarchovies”

      1. proud(ish) italian-american says:

        @proud(ish) italian-american i know this comment is a joke but FACT: this year’s vshow playbill sez the writers considered making camille’s a front for the mob as a plot point. WHY IS EVERYONE SILENCE ON THE ITALO-AMERICAN RACISM OF V118!?

  • i just want to say says:

    @i just want to say thanks to the entire cast, and, more importantly, to the creative team, for creating such a wonderful note on which to end the academic year. i tip my hat to you all! (especially john, jeff, solomon, and tareq. MAN you guys are great!)


  • rundown/spoilers says:

    @rundown/spoilers Favorite Lines:
    – “You can forget about that extra Commencement ticket!”

    – in the Stacks: “Oh look! From one of the Core originators in 19xx: “Please do some back-of-the-envelope calculations: “How much smaller is a woman’s brain?”
    “How about Chapter X! OrientalHum…”

    – Deantini: “Did you know there’s a 15-story coffee shop next to Pupin?”

    – Deantini’s C.U.N.T. and C.L.I.T.

    – “Beautiful, powerful Barnard bears against… actual bears.”

    – Siri at the gym.

    – Scrotum McGee.

    – “Can you sign my Phinead?”

    – the a capella (?) part of “Roar Lion Roar” was absolutely stunning. As in my breath fled and school spirit started leaking from my pores. It was very much an “UNTIL THE END” sort of spirit.

    – catching the spirit of disillusionment that most of the student body feels regarding: a. our reputation of churning out bankers, and b. crappy economy in general, and c. columbia not putting in a lot of effort in maintaining a happy student body.

    – Somehow, the Gulati-loving subplot did not get as old as I had imagined. It did bring some pretty good laughs.

    – Lexie and Claire and Niamh – wow, I thought the writers did a pretty decent job on these women characters in specific (see Dislikes for rebuttal). Lexie especially ran the risk of being a source of flatness, but she did quite well.

    – PIT ORCHESTRA. so much kudos this year for the composers.

    – Trolling in the Deep.

    – the main female characters were (overall) quite good and well-rounded (still issues, but…), but it seemed like all the background female characters couldn’t have passed a basic “is this a sexist portrayal?” test, no less Bechdel’s. They were all very focused on sex and boys (except for that one nice bit in the Stacks. Vaginal center, indeed!).

    – lol the racial diversity on the set. yes, i know auditioning is a long difficult arduous process, but still… it was very, um, white this year.

    – Pizza song was probably the weakest of the entire repertoire.

    – I thought resolution was a bit rushed? i.e. everything after final PowerPoint. Especially on Phineas’s side.

    1. Agreed says:

      @Agreed on the lack of diversity. It looked closer to Boston College than Columbia.

      But the cast did a great job!

    2. jk re: whiteness says:

      @jk re: whiteness haha would’ve been a different story if i had stayed to do the show.
      THAT BEING SAID, totally kicking myself right now, though; this show was absolutely amazing!

      1. Anonymous says:

        @Anonymous lol this is awk. why would you post this lol

    3. Anonymous says:

      @Anonymous too long, didn’t read

      1. Anonymous says:

        @Anonymous tl;dr

    4. Anonymous says:

      @Anonymous I agree on the racial diversity. That was one of the glaring things that negatively stood out in the show.

      Oh well, there’s always next year for more diversity!

  • um says:

    @um “…rather than try to work every scandal or significant event from the past year into the main plot, V118 instead distilled them into tremendously funny one-liners or asides…”

    You mean except for the song at the beginning of the second act, which was an absolutely spot-on parody of the Bwog comments section in the aftermath of Obamanard? And the scene following where Niamh got called by the major news outlets and said pretty much whatever it was PrezBo and DSpar said? Not only was this hilarious, it was probably one of the best satirical moments I’ve seen in any VShow.

  • Anonymous says:

    @Anonymous Columbia is the best!

  • reasons i want to see this a billion times says:

    @reasons i want to see this a billion times #clairenotpears

    ^ THIS.

    1. wait says:

      @wait can you explain this? idgi

      1. Anonymous says:

        @Anonymous In Book 2 of St. Augustine’s Confessions, he mentions how he and his friends stole pears when they were teens. St. Augustine finds this event so significant he confesses at length of his great “pear thieving” sin.

        1. ohhh says:

          @ohhh thanks! #cluelessseaskid

  • cc '12 says:

    @cc '12 i wish they were selling a recording of the songs for this one

    1. As always says:

      @As always I’m sure the recordings will be available on some time next semester!

    2. Roar Lion Roar recording! says:

      @Roar Lion Roar recording! YAY

  • So says:

    @So I absolutely loved the show. Definitely the best one I’ve seen. Congratulations to the cast, crew, and creative team. The sets were beautiful, the talent off the walls.

    But seriously, how has no one mentioned the complete and total inconsistency of the Barnard character? Other than saying “I go to Barnard” like twelve times, she seemed to go to CC. She fought in Alma’s Army, ran into Phineas’ room without being signed in, seemed to have a huge stake in the core curriculum….didn’t make sense. I thought the show was amazing but as a Barnard student, I couldn’t relate to anything, because that character didn’t even seem to go to Barnard and the whole plot was about the core.

    1. Can't write convincing women says:

      @Can't write convincing women unless you have at least one female writer.

      Sad, but true.

      1. Anonymous says:

        @Anonymous Anna Karenina was crap.

      2. kaylin mahoney says:

        @kaylin mahoney is fucking hilarious and should write next year’s show

  • BC '12 says:

    @BC '12 I don’t think that’s possible.

    1. cc'12 says:

      @cc'12 the limit does not exist! the limit does not exist!

  • CC '14 says:

    @CC '14 I was absolutely blown away by this year’s vshow. The music, the singing, the writing, and even the set design were all wonderful, and I must say I was VERY impressed by the sheer level of talent the wonderful cast and crew had to offer the Columbia community.

    And also, I think I’m in love with Phineas.

  • CC '13 says:

    @CC '13 hey yo bwog. If possible (it’s probably not), could you interview niamh o’brien about being the subject of this year’s show and what she thought about the production/the message/the “misinterpretation” of what CCE is about? I would really like to read that.

    … Just thought I’d ask.

  • Can we talk about Deantini for a hot sec. says:

    @Can we talk about Deantini for a hot sec. 1. Holy shit, so funny.
    2. That rap was the highlight of my Columbia experience.
    3. “I got my job by killing Moody-Adams!”
    4. “Did you know there’s a 15-story coffee shop next to Pupin?”
    5. Could go on forever.

    (I’m really just asking if Gray Henry is single).

    1. Anonymous says:

      @Anonymous sorry, he’s taken.

    2. Anonymous says:

      @Anonymous Gray Henry is amazing.

  • Anonymous says:

    @Anonymous The fake Kingsman “Cum Dumpster” flyer with PrezBo’s face was the best sight-gag I have ever seen. AMAZING

    1. Anonymous says:

      @Anonymous Whoa, I totally didn’t see that. #balconyproblems

  • seas12 says:

    @seas12 Jenny Singer looks so much like Rebecca Black!

    1. Anonymous says:

      @Anonymous that just isn’t true

    2. Anonymous says:

      @Anonymous Whatchu talkin’ bout? Jenny Singer is freaking hot. And her voice is absolutely fantastic.

  • Orli Matlow says:

    @Orli Matlow now i feel compelled to come out of the shadows!
    *pretension alert*
    the best theatrical experiences have you feel enlightened and perhaps even compel you to change your behavior and this show successfully did so!
    *end of pretension zone/run on sentence*

    MAZEL TOV to everyone involved! it was a truly fantastic show!!
    Also, Sean Walsh needs to play Elder McKinley in “The Book of Mormon”!!!

  • Anonymous says:

    @Anonymous Does anybody know if Gulati has a wife?????

    1. Anonymous says:

      @Anonymous i know he has a son

    2. Anonymous says:

      @Anonymous yeah he does

    3. yup says:

      @yup She was at the show on Friday with him

  • also, says:

    @also, jizz holes.



  • Anonymous says:

    @Anonymous Do you all realize that we are making comments on BWOG just like they did in V118?!?! So cool right?! :D

    1. Anonymous says:

      @Anonymous Meta.

  • awesome says:

    @awesome it was genius

  • Schoolhouse Rock! says:

    @Schoolhouse Rock! ♫♫♪

  • copy editrix says:

    @copy editrix Bwog,

    -Independent clauses after a colon get a capital letter.
    -Lists have parallel structure.

    What does it say about the quality of your editors that this is the first sentence of the one article you write painstakingly as an entire staff?

    1. Anonymous says:

      @Anonymous Thanks, Ms. Prescriptivist. Those weren’t necessary. Some might even say your first rule is falling out of fashion.

  • also says:

    @also was anyone else wondering how the main guy’s Barnard gf was able to get into his dorm room?

  • waah graduating says:

    @waah graduating No seriously guys. this year’s show is awesome. go see it.

    1. wait so... says:

      @wait so... she was an actual irish step dancer? what is this world?!

    2. That's probably says:

      @That's probably a different Niamh O’Brien. It’s not an uncommon name in Ireland. Then again, her CCE bio says “When Niamh is not working, she likes to dance and do crossword puzzles.” So you never know.

    3. cc'12 says:


  • Loved it says:

    @Loved it Best VShow since I’ve been here and the first one to make me realize the point of Vshow for our campus. The pizza song was totally weird but the bwog song and the stunning rendition of Roar Lions Roar more than made up for it. The cast was brilliant and the story, while a bit choppy at the beginning, was really sweet and fun. Also, that set (and the various projection and lighting effects) was epic. So glad that this is the one I leave on.

  • Anonymous says:

    @Anonymous Little heavy on the Gulati references

  • Anonymous says:

    @Anonymous I liked the Spooky Mormon Hell Dream ripoff.

    1. Anonymous says:

      @Anonymous Legit.

  • Anonymous says:

    @Anonymous Niamh O’Brien…y u keep sending me e-mails I will never read?

    1. Anonymous says:

      @Anonymous I once emailed her and requested to be removed from her list. Her response:

      “Hi, [name]! Unfortunately, I cannot remove you from this list, since it is the undergraduate list and I do not have access. However, I hope you will continue to utilize CCE resources!”

  • Ooohhh says:

    @Ooohhh Bwog mentions the author’s name! Well no one can say they don’t learn their lesson.

  • Anonymous says:

    @Anonymous So we’re back to plot summary mode on Bwog, I see.

  • Wasn't there says:

    @Wasn't there A pit orchestra?

    1. Anonymous says:

      @Anonymous a beautiful 27 piece one in fact! it was epic (pun intended)

  • Anonymous says:

    @Anonymous I loved the show. Especially the dancing pizzas and the inferno disco.

    1. Anonymous says:

      @Anonymous I loved the show, except the dancing pizzas and the inferno disco.

  • Creampuff Tyrd says:

    @Creampuff Tyrd I am pleased with this review.

    1. Scrotumface McGee says:

      @Scrotumface McGee As am I

      1. The Righteous Shadow says:

        @The Righteous Shadow Youre name is insulting and I am disgusted that the spec would allow such FILTH on their blog. I have RESPECT for the varsity show I am very excited to see it!

        1. Anonymous says:

          @Anonymous Fail.

        2. please bwog says:

          @please bwog just ban this poster’s IP. he’s all over spec too

          1. Anonymous says:

            @Anonymous IP addresses don’t correspond to people. There’s not much we can do but ignore it.

            1. The Righteous Shadow says:

              @The Righteous Shadow Or you can join the spec-sucks cause and take down the spec once and for all!

              1. Anonymous says:

                @Anonymous Why are you an idiot.

  • Have Your Say

    What should Bwog's new tagline be?

    View Results

    Loading ... Loading ...

    Recent Comments

    Wish this post existed when I went to Columbia. Well said. (read more)
    Things We Wish We Knew Our First-Year
    August 7, 2020
    It's thermometers *with* mercury that are prohibited (not without). (read more)
    Bwog’s Approved Packing List: Pandemic Edition
    August 7, 2020
    thank you so much for the advice!! - incoming freshman here :D (read more)
    A Bwogger’s Guide To Good First-Year Classes: Fall 2020 Edition
    August 7, 2020
    Discrete math is like baby's first college math class, chill out brother (read more)
    A Bwogger’s Guide To Good First-Year Classes: Fall 2020 Edition
    August 4, 2020

    Comment Policy

    The purpose of Bwog’s comment section is to facilitate honest and open discussion between members of the Columbia community. We encourage commenters to take advantage of—without abusing—the opportunity to engage in anonymous critical dialogue with other community members. A comment may be moderated if it contains:
    • A slur—defined as a pejorative derogatory phrase—based on ethnicity, race, gender, sexual orientation, ability, or spiritual belief
    • Hate speech
    • Unauthorized use of a person’s identity
    • Personal information about an individual
    • Baseless personal attacks on specific individuals
    • Spam or self-promotion
    • Copyright infringement
    • Libel
    • COVID-19 misinformation