Connect with us

All Articles

Marching Band Prohibited From Playing Orgo Night In Butler 209

According to an email to the CU Marching Band Alumni Association from association director Sam Rowan, members of the Band leadership met yesterday with Chief Librarian and Vice Provost Ann Thornton. Thornton informed them that the Band would not be allowed to hold Orgo Night in Butler 209.  Orgo Night, the Band’s traditional end-of-semester event critiquing events at Columbia during the past semester and bringing the community together, has been held in this room in Butler on the last night of Reading Week for decades. This semester’s Orgo Night is happening this Thursday, at 11:59pm.

As for reasons behind this change, Thornton said that she was concerned about the disruption Orgo Night causes to students right before final exams. She suggested that the Band move their event to Roone Arledge Auditorium, in Lerner.

We have reached out to the Band, and were told that they will be releasing a statement with more details on the situation soon. We will update this post once we receive that statement.

UPDATE as of 7:19 pm, 12/13/16: Liz Pudel, BC ‘18 and Head Manager of the Band, has sent us an official statement on behalf of the Band’s Board that provides more details on their meetings with Vice Provost Ann Thornton, as well as their response to the prohibition.

The statement explains that members of the Board have met with Vice Provost Thornton and Provost John Coatsworth twice in the past week. During their first meeting last Wednesday, they were told that Orgo Night could no longer take place in Butler because of its disruptive nature; they argued with the decision, and this meeting ended with an agreement to take the weekend to consider possible compromises and meet again on Monday. Then, during yesterday’s meeting, the Band offered several concessions, but Coatsworth and Thornton were unwilling to consider them, and did not offer concessions of their own. The Band leaders were “shocked and blindsided by their unwillingness to compromise as per [both parties’] agreement in the previous meeting,” and “disturbed and disappointed with the blatant lack of respect for what has become a widely-beloved campus tradition.”

The Board then went on to state that “the administration’s reluctance to even consider [the Band’s] proposals combined with the lack of prudence on their part in informing [the Band] in a timely and appropriate fashion has put incredible strain on [them] in finding alternative arrangements.” They also cited Orgo Night’s long history; this event dates back to 1975 in its Butler 209 location. The Band chose Butler, this statement says, because “Butler Library is an iconic location on campus, and in choosing to enter Butler, the Band disrupts not just a library but also this campus’s pervasive stress culture.” The Band members wrote that Orgo Night’s “benefits as a destressing mechanism and a community-building event far outweigh the cost of disrupting one reading room in one of the many study spaces on campus for less than an hour.”

The statement concludes by calling out Provost and Vice Provost on their disrespect towards their students and misplaced priorities. “Not only are they undermining decades worth of tradition,” the Board wrote, “but they are also making it clear to Columbia at large that fostering a community is not their priority.” Finally, the Band vowed to “keep fighting the good fight against the War on Fun.”

UPDATE as of 8:31 pm, 12/13/16: The Band has released their second round of posters, several of which are in response to their prohibition from Butler. These posters have been added below the jump.

CUMB Statement by betsy on Scribd

The Band causing disturbance via their Facebook page

Write a comment

Your email address will not be published.



  • what says:

    @what the fuck



  • Anonymous says:

    @Anonymous ann thornton = snake ??

  • DarkEn says:

    @DarkEn Muh freedums

  • Another war on fun casualty says:

    @Another war on fun casualty Bacchanal, on campus parties, greek life, near-campus bars.

    The administration wants you to just sit in your room and do your work, but don’t be stressed or kill yourself, so we can check off some nice boxes about underage drinking statistics and risk management.

    1. anon says:

      @anon Don’t worry there are puppy breaks and free massages so we don’t blow our brains out!!

  • PC Principal says:

    @PC Principal As an alumnus, goddammit Columbia. The campus is censoring more and more every year. All in the name of protecting precious little snowflake students. If you got into Columbia, you should be smart enough to study somewhere else than room 209 for the 1 1/2 hours of the year Orgo night takes up.

  • Anonymous says:

    @Anonymous PC culture run amuck. Anything you say or do can “hurt” someone.

  • Sandy & Crusty says:

    @Sandy & Crusty Yet another shot fired in the War on Fun. I hope the band and the Columbia community fight this dumbass decision.

  • Pissed off and still going says:

    @Pissed off and still going This is fucking ridiculous. Columbia administration needs to get its head out of its fucking ass

  • RAGE says:

    @RAGE Students have limited time this week as it is, I wonder if the administration’s short-notice meeting was a tactical move to weaken the chance of protest and increase the likelihood of CUMB capitulating. If so, they are snakes and I hope to see Butler 209 taken over for twice as long with twice as dark jokes.

    Do your thing CUMB.

  • Ann Thornton says:

    @Ann Thornton 🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍

  • deebius says:

    @deebius “We don’t ban speech. We don’t censor speech.

    Now, I do not for a second want you to think that this is a simple, clear-cut, self-evident principle or policy. You hear a lot of people these days talking as if this were all perfectly obvious and no reasonable person could believe otherwise. I have spent a good part of my life trying to understand why this approach is indeed the right and sound way to structure a society or a university. But I can assure you, it is highly complicated. Nevertheless, it is the choice—it is our choice—and you should know that at this University, you cannot expect the institution to intervene, to stop thoughts or viewpoints many of us may dislike, and deeply so. And we will not let others do what we cannot.”

    -President Bollinger, 2016 Convocation Address

    1. ballinger says:

      @ballinger woops. jkjkjk.

  • Wealthy Alumnus says:

    @Wealthy Alumnus Fire Ann Thornton and like this comment.

  • Anonymous says:

    @Anonymous Find me literally one student who is in support of this.

    1. i exist says:

      @i exist me

  • Anonymous says:

    @Anonymous im gonna fight the administration

  • Anonymous says:

    @Anonymous NYT Feb 1, 2019!

    End the #waronfun! I will redirect my alumni giving to a gofundme for the band if they create one.

    1. Anonymous says:

      @Anonymous You can also give to the Columbia Band Alumni Association –>

  • Have Your Say

    What should you actually Venmo people for?

    View Results

    Loading ... Loading ...

    Recent Comments

    BC - Barnard is one of the constituent colleges of Columbia University, together with SEAS, GS, CC, and the graduate (read more)
    Columbia Class Of 2024 Early Decision Results Have Been Released
    December 14, 2019
    trash (read more)
    Bwog On Aux: Study Playlists
    December 13, 2019

    Comment Policy

    The purpose of Bwog’s comment section is to facilitate honest and open discussion between members of the Columbia community. We encourage commenters to take advantage of—without abusing—the opportunity to engage in anonymous critical dialogue with other community members. A comment may be moderated if it contains:
    • A slur—defined as a pejorative derogatory phrase—based on ethnicity, race, gender, sexual orientation, ability, or spiritual belief
    • Hate speech
    • Unauthorized use of a person’s identity
    • Personal information about an individual
    • Baseless personal attacks on specific individuals
    • Spam or self-promotion
    • Copyright infringement
    • Libel